Compiled data from mafia game

Bluepotato

Good

2016/07/31 Bluepotato is one of early players to attack M. Poireau, Snife supports this move.

2016/07/31 Bluepotato goes into verbal conflict with M. Poireau in chat

2016/08/04 M. Poireau: Watch out for people using the term “general consensus” to refer to attacking other players… This “general consensus” appears to be a group of about 3-6 players who are coordinating an attack incredibly well. I urge you to draw your own conclusions! (very high chance majority of the concensus is town up to that point in game)

2016/08/08 M. Poireau: Allow the cabal of Tabby, oljo, HankyPinky, and Bluepotato to eliminate me.(Bluepotato might be townie, attackers not mentioned might be mafia)

2016/08/14 M. Poireau again suspects Bluepotato to be mafia

2016/10/09 Bluepotato: (regarding M. Poireau) I’m almost completely certain he was mafia, but it would be awkward if he wasn’t.

2016/10/10 Bluepotato and awesome explain to M. Poireau why exactly he was considered to be mafia (helping lucar/dividing people/being a likely choice for mafia member/accusing his attackers for being mafia)

2017/04/29 Bluepotato Alright, so here’s my defence of myself: I haven’t engaged in any wars against anyone but AI, have cooperated with all my neighbors such as by letting them complete bonuses, and dauti who was a townie trusted me enough to give me his lands.

2017/05/11 Bluepotato wants to make a vote before actual action happening.

Neutral

2016/07/13 Bluepotato believes that M. Poireau is likely to be mafia, because he’s the host and could have unfair advantage otherwise.

2016/07/22 When bluepotato was called mafia by Hankypinky, he responded with claim that HankyPinky is mafia

2016/07/22 M. Poireau fine with claim fight (maybe bluepotato is town)

2016/07/26 Bluepotato supports eliminating luccar and semice, doesn’t mention bigheaded

2016/07/28 Bluepotato calls Tabby mafia and blaims him on making fake arguments (might be a good point)

2016/08/03 Bluepotato thinks that semice is clearly mafia

2016/08/12 Bluepotato: I have permission to take Brandywine

2016/10/30 Some town members and Bluepotato accuse Phakh Gokhn of being mafia member. Phakh Gokhn defends by asking to reconsiderate their opinions and wait till all AIs get eliminated. He claims to be working on behalf of town and that he intends to work for it till his very elimination. Also tries to seek income equality and promises to gift 2 territories to smaller players.

2016/11/04 Niobium Certain that Phakh Gokhn is Mafia member, Bluepotato uncertain about issue.

2016/11/10 Bluepotato is certain that both Dauti and Phakh Gokhn are town members

2017/01/12 Oilspotter “nicely” asks Bluepotato not to attack him. Bluepotato responds that he has no such intentions and that Oilspotter’s response is overly hostile.

2017/01/15 Bluepotato gives riverpath to Tom Cook

2017/04/08 Bluepotato claims that if dauti is townie, he must be townie too.

2017/04/08 Dauti allows Bluepotato to take his territories.

2017/04/12 Oilspotters considers Bluepotato town member and also asks for Stormy Timberland from Snife and wants to split Lush Lark Woods with Niobium2

2017/04/12 Oilspotter gives permission for Bluepotato to take Smiling Fish territory.

2017/04/12 in case of boots Bluepotato thinks about keeping stacks on borders and also suspects quiter players of potentially being mafia.

2017/04/12 Niobium2 allows Oilspotter to take Lush Lark Woods and also allows Vaste Resort to be taken by either by bigheaded or bluepotato.

2017/04/28 oilspotter, bigheaded and bluepotato asked for voting (3 mafia were alive at that point)

2017/05/05 Bluepotato believes oilspotter to be innocent.

Bad

2016/07/22 HankyPinky: Bluepotato intentionally entered his claimed bonus which Hanky had already entered past turn.

2017/05/19 Bluepotato claims that snife suggested to vote to eliminate Phakh.

Awesomeusername

Good

2016/07/17 Awesome: Strong faith in Lucarr or bigheaded being mafia

2016/07/19 Awesome: First suspicions on M poreu

2016/07/26 awesome keeps challenging m. poireau

2016/07/26 M. poireau tells to look at who supports tabby. High likelyhood that those supporters are townie

2016/08/04 M. Poireau: Watch out for people using the term “general consensus” to refer to attacking other players… This “general consensus” appears to be a group of about 3-6 players who are coordinating an attack incredibly well. I urge you to draw your own conclusions! (very high chance majority of the concensus is town up to that point in game)

2016/08/12 M. Poireau: awesomeusername, are you also part of this cabal?

2016/09/11 awesome: BigHeaded is not confirmed town but he is pretty likely to be town at this point + This is very good news though – I was fairly confident Lucarr was mafia but I didn’t suspect Azul

2016/08/20 Awesome: If luccar is townie, we should eliminate bigheaded

2016/10/10 Bluepotato and awesome explain to M. Poireau why exactly he was considered to be mafia (helping lucar/dividing people/being a likely choice for mafia member/accusing his attackers for being mafia)

2016/12/17 Awesome and Snife opposes M. Poireau on making lowest income players PEs

2016/12/19 Awesome considers Bigheaded to be Town member

2017/05/03 awesome suggests that everyone would make initial vote and send it to a trusted person, so then the real vote comes up, it would be uninfluenced by other votes (makes it harder for mafia to influence voting)

Neutral

2016/07/16 Awesomeusername: supports killing both bigheaded and Lucarr

2016/07/17 Awesome: Why lucarr over Bigheaded (maybe good thing)

2016/08/03 awesome not sure why to attack semice

2016/09/02 awesome seeks honesty about roles after player gets eliminated   

2016/09/07 awesome: For the record, I still think he’s(Tabby) a civilian, but I am eager to see this flip…

2017/05/05 awesome says that he reread chat and believes that Tom Cook or Niobium is mafia and that oilspotter/Phakh could be mafia too.

Bad

2016/07/13 awesomeusername very suprised by message system

2016/07/13 awesome: we can just trace Message 3 backwards, each time asking who it was received from, until someone denies sending it

Oilspotter

Good

2017/04/30 Oilspotter: I haven’t engaged in any wars against anyone but AI, have cooperated with all my neighbors such as by letting them complete bonuses.

Neutral

2016/07/18 Oilspotter: Hankypinky is too keen on eliminating players

2016/07/28 Oilspotter: Timelord has “surrendered” but stacks armies up on my border. The only players not to accept his “surrender” are Tabby and Takacho. Not that I’m paranoid or anything…

2016/08/15 Oilspotter: tldr. can someone summarise who is mafia and who isn’t?

2016/09/02 Oilspotter: Haha “honest mafia member” is that as rare as an honest politician…?

2016/10/23 Dauti requests help versus Phakh Gokhn, Oilspotter agrees to help

2016/10/29 Dauti gifts oilspotter a territory and Phakh Gokhn knocks it out without war declaration. Later says that he did that because that territory was dauti’s before and in his opinion didn’t belong to oilspotter.

2017/01/12 Oilspotter “nicely” asks Bluepotato not to attack him. Bluepotato responds that he has no such intentions and that Oilspotter’s response is overly hostile.

2017/01/21 Oilspotters holds smilling fish for safety reasons.

2017/02/01 Tom Cook agrees to split his big stack and promises not to become AI after Oilspotters asks about it.

2017/02/20 Oilspotter is afraid that mafia will win

2017/04/08 Oilspotter calls everyone coward for staying passive.

2017/04/09 Oilspotter: If Phakh is mafia then he’s dangerous because he’s the strongest player. My vote would be to eliminate him before he gets any bigger.

2017/04/12 Oilspotters considers Bluepotato town member and also asks for Stormy Timberland from Snife and wants to split Lush Lark Woods with Niobium2

2017/04/12 Oilspotter gives permission for Bluepotato to take Smiling Fish territory.

2017/04/12 Niobium2 allows Oilspotter to take Lush Lark Woods and also allows Vaste Resort to be taken by either by bigheaded or bluepotato.

2017/04/28 oilspotter, bigheaded and bluepotato asked for voting (3 mafia were alive at that point)

2017/05/18 Oilspotter is suspicious of snife and Tom for “obvious reasons”. Doesn’t know how many mafia left or whether bluepotao voted to eliminate Phakh.

Bad

2016/07/13 Oilspotter suggests to tell who didn’t receive any message (hard to prove)

2016/08/19 Oilspotter: I don’t think we can assume Stannis was civilian until we hear from him. Maybe he realised that the mafia has little to no chance of success, and gave up? (Stannis didn’t even bother to take a territory from very 1st turn) I don’t think there’s any real way the mafia can win this, all we have to do is sit tight and wait for them to attack. There needs to be some other random element in the game, like each turn a randomly picked player has to declare war on a player of their choosing for 5 turns. As it is now, even if we just started eliminating players at random, we’d still probably get the mafia before all the civilians. (random wars are beneficial to mafia)

2016/08/23 Oilspotter requests Dauti to not attack his territory (dauti has all remaining territories in the bonus)

2016/09/07 Oilspotter very quick to assume that redonblue and Phakh Gokhn are mafia (might be neutral)

2016/10/24 Oilspotter: np Hanky, mainly just looking to alleviate the boredom without opening myself up to accustaions… Dauti, I’ll help you out – thanks!

2016/11/03 For some reason oilspotter didn’t know Lucarr10′ role by that point in game

2017/04/28 Oilspotter: I think it’s time to call a vote on who to eliminate next. Are we all ok with doing this? If you’re not, speak up. We’ll have to take silence as consent, and if we have a simple majority in favour of voting by sunday midday (pacific time), then all survivng players will vote. If there’s a tie then Dauti will have the casting vote (as the last confirmed townie to expire -> he could only know as much reliable information as any of us + he’s clearly in support of eliminating Phakh). Let’s say 24 hours to cast your vote from the time the vote is called. All those in agreement say “Yes”. If not, say “No” (or “nein” if you want to annoy Bluepotato). If yo say nothing, you’ll be counted as a Yes.

2017/04/30 Oilspotter asks wether Snife supports voting or not even though snife previously said that he doesn’t support it.

2017/05/02 Oilspotter The vote to eliminate is happening, more people wanted it than didn’t (Technically it was 4/8). I have to admit I initially didn’t but this game needs a kick in the arse…

2017/05/03 Oilspotter: I was initally against the vote, because it seemed unfair, and was suggested by dead mafia. But realistically, we have no other options here (I’m not so certain). I’m certainly not going to make a move against anyone without provocation, and I doubt anyone else will. And waiting for boots is very, very dull. Let’s get into the spirit of the game and see what this one vote turns up. We might get some clues by how people vote, or how people act after the vote. I think three votes with reasons helps the mafia (it helps undecided town to make better decisions) because they will know who is close to being right (1 vote shows who’s close to right too), and how to behave to allay suspicion (are you in support of less educated choices?). One vote, plain and simple, no need to tell all the hitmen that you think they’re hitmen and why… I suspect the mafia will vote last, and try to undermine the vote, or confuse the issue (good point).

2017/05/04 Oilspotter critizes awesome’s idea to make early private vote, pursues basic 1 vote idea. Believes that awesome’s idea could be manipulated by mafia (i don’t see how it makes it easier for them to manipulate)

2017/05/04 Oilspotter objects Phak’s idea of talking out who is mafia, blames him for trying to dodge getting voted out.

2017/05/11 Oilspotter blames snife on making to quick decision on his role. (is he trying to change opinion?)

Niobium2

Good

2016/10/31 Niobium supports eliminating Phakh Gokhn, Snife is neutral on the issue.

2016/11/04 Niobium Certain that Phakh Gokhn is Mafia member, Bluepotato uncertain about issue.

Neutral

2016/07/14 Niobium2 if I was mafia I would say I received no messages

2016/07/17 Niobium: talks about stagnation without escalating need for action

2016/07/22 Niobium 1 week vacation

2016/08/19 Snife and Niobium2 openly support fighting AIs

2016/11/08 Niobium withdraws his claim on attacking Phakh Gokhn after he declares that he won’t be defending.

2017/01/25 Phakh allows Niobium to retake Narrow Way

2017/01/25 Niobium2 wants to eliminate AIs before proceeding with attacking players.

2017/02/02 Niobium2 declares that he will set all borders to 10.

2017/03/24 Niobium2 in advance informs that he’ll be going for vacations.

2017/04/12 Oilspotters considers Bluepotato town member and also asks for Stormy Timberland from Snife and wants to split Lush Lark Woods with Niobium2

2017/04/12 Niobium2 allows Oilspotter to take Lush Lark Woods and also allows Vaste Resort to be taken by either by bigheaded or bluepotato.

2017/04/29 Niobium2 supports voting, believes that it could give insight on other player roles.

2017/05/05 Niobium votes to eliminate Phakh because of his previous conflict with dauti and private conversations between him and Phakh.

Bad

2017/01/01 Niobium2 (to oljo): That would be nice, but I think it’s still fair to say that you should cede some of your territory for being booted so often.

Snife

Good

2016/07/17 Snife: M Pourieu is likely mafia

2016/07/25 Snife oposes M. Poireau, says that mafia only would support mafia member elimination if they can’t save him

2016/07/27 Snife calls out lucar for being mafia

2016/07/31 Bluepotato is one of early players to attack M. Poireau, Snife supports this move.

2016/08/01 Snife and Azul appear to not communicate their moves

2016/08/01 Azul considers himself unsafe versus phakh gokhn and snife

2016/09/02 Snife: I like how you are still trying to convince us that you are a civilian Poireau 😉

2016/09/27 Snife 100% sure M. Poireau is Mafia

2016/12/17 Awesome and Snife opposes M. Poireau on making lowest income players PEs

Neutral

2016/07/21 Snife: Appears to consider Tabby mafia

2016/07/28 Snife calls tabby mafia because: lucarr wrote: “can you atleast try and make it seem like you are not also mafia”. Sounds like a confession to me. (might be good + snife is not 100% sure on this)

2016/08/02 Snife attacked Azul because he was AI and didn’t move out because of wastelands in Azul’s bonus.

2016/08/04 Snife in advance informs about 5 days vacation

2016/08/10 snife trades  Elusive Island with smart james back and forth for card pieces

2016/08/16 Snife asks Stannis if he was town.

2016/08/19 Snife and Niobium2 openly support fighting AIs

2016/08/30 Snife: imagine if only citizens have become AIs yet… we would be in big trouble 😦

2016/09/15 Snife and Oljo both gift bigheaded a territory.

2016/10/26 Snife thinks that both Phakh and Dauti might be town members

2016/10/31 Niobium supports eliminating Phakh Gokhn, Snife is neutral on the issue.

2017/02/22 Snife claims not to be mafia and ask for his support so that at least 1 town member would survive.

2017/03/29 Snife: I think I am one of the most trustworthy players in this game 😀

2017/04/12 Oilspotters considers Bluepotato town member and also asks for Stormy Timberland from Snife and wants to split Lush Lark Woods with Niobium2

2017/04/12 Snife negotiates on territory ownership in west, threacherous rapids and Green Covert.

2017/04/24 Snife: don’t be surprised. I am just making some suicide moves. You should not loose any unit.

2017/04/29 Snife doesn’t support voting but expresses need for action

2017/05/04 Snife states that he has reread majority of chat and that he believes Oilspotter to be mafia.

2017/05/11 snife demands action

2017/05/18 Oilspotter is suspicious of snife and Tom for “obvious reasons”. Doesn’t know how many mafia left or whether bluepotao voted to eliminate Phakh.

2017/05/18 Phakh Gokhn claims to have compilation of past events, snife wants to see it.

Bad

2016/07/14 Snife 1st to suggest tabby to be mafia (might be wrong)

2016/07/14 Snife: shoot first ask later

2016/07/15 Snife suggests: Order someone to say in public chat that’s someone is a mafia

2016/07/17 Snife: Tabby is mafia (why)

2016/07/17 Snife: Types of mafia (basically everyone is a potential mafia)

2016/07/17 Azul suggests Phakh to give bonus to Snife, doesn’t even recognize there are other players neighbouring that bonus.

2016/07/17 Azul: Silent players might become suspicous (so are the mafia more of a talkative kind in this game?) also case of supporting Snife

2016/07/20 Snife: It is ok to kill someone even if you are not 100% sure he is evil (might be a good point related to lucarr and Bigheaded).

2016/09/09 Snife: saving town member doesn’t make much sense. (declares redonblue and Phakh Gokhn potential mafia)(might be neutral)

2016/09/10 M. Poireau is first to declare confirmed townie – Stannis. Others for some reason are not confirmed. Snife was first to declare Stannis town (might be mafia evidence for Snife)

Phakh

Good

2016/07/17 Azul suggests Phakh to give bonus to Snife, doesn’t even recognize there are other players neighbouring that bonus.

2016/07/17 Azul Claims one bonus so Phakh would have less bonuses

2016/07/17 Azul: Phakh has too much bonuses

2016/08/01 Azul considers himself unsafe versus phakh gokhn and snife

2016/11/05 Phakh Gokhn declares that he won’t defend against attacks on him, because it’s pointless for town members to infight.

2016/11/08 Phakh Gokhn makes a deal with Lord Bomber to help him take down neutrals in his territories.

2017/03/01 Phakh Gokhn allows Dauti to evacuate Seeking roots.

2017/05/04 Phakh says that players should talk it out on who is mafia, because not everyone supports 1 vote idea, also says that players should be only judged by their previous actions and words, not personal likes.

2017/05/18 Phakh Gokhn claims to have compilation of past events, snife wants to see it.

Neutral

2016/07/18 Phakh is fine with Stannis quiting (because stannis didn’t take any territory and doesn’t enjoy the game)

2016/08/02 Phakh Gokhn declares that he doesn’t cooperate with Snife

2016/08/27 Phakh Gokhn: It’s just my opinion, but I think mafia members could try to get themselves booted to start attacks on others without blame. (in response in azul getting repeatedly booted)

2016/09/07 Phakh Gokhn announces that he’s protecting Redonblue

2016/10/05 Phakh Gokhn: Regarding Dauti situation, if RedonBlue turns out to be mafia, I will cease my attacks against Dauti. Redonblue is already an AI so I am no longer protecting him.

2016/10/12 Phakh Gokhn is eager to find Redonblue’s role

2016/10/28 Phakh Gokhn pushes to have peace with Dauti, abandons plans to get Oakfort, asks for at that time full with wastelands Maple Edge bonus

2016/10/28 Phakh Gokhn says he wanted peace with Dauti for long time (lack of evidence)

2016/10/29 Dauti and Phakh Gokhn agree for peace. Phakh Gokhn receives Maple Edge and Dauti receives Molten Run.

2016/11/08 Niobium withdraws his claim on attacking Phakh Gokhn after he declares that he won’t be defending.

2016/11/08 Phakh Gokhn asks Dauti to let Lord Bomber take Babbling Sewage.

2017/01/25 Phakh allows Niobium to retake Narrow Way

2017/03/11 Phakh Gokhn takes 10 days vacation and gets booted, once back claims that the reason for that was his father’s death.

2017/04/28 Phakh Suggests to give lists of 3 suspected players, explaination why voter is not mafia, investigate past events and look for 3 cooperating players combinations. Believes that single player vote is too biased and that Bigheaded/actionguy could have both been mafia to ensure one of them surviving.

2017/05/04 Phakh states that he has no intentions to change player opinions.

2017/05/10 Phakh gets booted and doesn’t notice it. He’s suprised that not much has happened regarding mafia hunt.

Bad

2016/07/17 Phakh to Azul: Nope Earlington is mine at any cost

2016/07/17 Phakh Gokh doesn’t buy into lucarr or Bigheaded being a mafia.

2016/09/09 Phakh Gokhn appoligizes for not seeing Redonblue to be the 1st one to attack dauti, also claims that he’s only concern is to maintain peace and doesn’t like doing nothing because of army cap

2016/10/03 Dauti has suspicions about Phakh Gokhn

2016/10/06 Dauti: you(Phakh Gokhn) are not protecting him?  he has been ai for some turn now and you dont atack him, but you are willing to break wastelands to reach me and attack me

2016/10/23 Dauti requests help versus Phakh Gokhn, Oilspotter agrees to help

2016/10/24 Phakh Gokhn tries to negotiate with dauti in public chat claiming dauti didn’t respond to his mail. Agressively demands Molten Run and Oakfort. Asks for peace with Dauti and says that only want to have presence near dauti in case trouble in region arise. (note: redonblue was eliminated long ago and only 1 bonus was enough to have presence near Dauti)

Dauti gifts oilspotter a territory and Phakh Gokhn knocks it out without war declaration. Later says that he did that because that territory was dauti’s before and in his opinion didn’t belong to oilspotter.

2016/10/30 Some town members and Bluepotato accuse Phakh Gokhn of being mafia member. Phakh Gokhn defends by asking to reconsiderate their opinions and wait till all AIs get eliminated. He claims to be working on behalf of town and that he intends to work for it till his very elimination. Also tries to seek income equality and promises to gift 2 territories to smaller players.

2016/10/30 Phakh Gokhn receives Lucarr10 sympathies in chat.

2017/02/20 Phakh claims Seeking roots, says that Dauti didn’t respond to his private messages so he assumes that Dauti doesn’t mind it

2017/04/09 Dauti blames Phakh Gokhn for attacking without warning.

2017/04/09 Dauti and Phakh Gokhn have an argument. Dauti blames Phakh Gokhn for attacking Maple Edge. Phakh Gokhn retaliates with claims that Maple Edge was part of previous peace deal and that he’s taking regardless of Dauti’s actions. He also blamed Dauti on poor communication and called out bluepotato eliminating dauti as a potential way to compromise Phakh Gokhn’s reputation and cause infighting between town members.

Tom

Good

2016/07/16 Lucarr: Tom Cook is alone in his bonus

2016/07/17 Azul: Silent players might become suspicous (so are the mafia more of a talkative kind in this game?) also case of supporting Snife

2017/02/01 Tom Cook agrees to split his big stack and promises not to become AI after Oilspotters asks about it.

Neutral

2017/01/15 Bluepotato gives riverpath to Tom Cook

2017/04/12 in case of boots Bluepotato thinks about keeping stacks on borders and also suspects quiter players of potentially being mafia.

2017/05/04 Tom Cook states that he has reread majority of chat and that he believes Oilspotter to be mafia.

2017/05/18 Oilspotter is suspicious of snife and Tom for “obvious reasons”. Doesn’t know how many mafia left or whether bluepotao voted to eliminate Phakh.

Bad

Big Headed

Good

2016/07/17 Azul: Silent players might become suspicous (so are the mafia more of a talkative kind in this game?) also case of supporting Snife

2016/07/17 Bigheaded: Accepts his elimination for the better good.

2016/07/22 bigheaded: it seems like a bit of a stretch to accuse someone of being mafia just because they didn’t stay out of your claim.

2016/07/25 Tabby: M. Poireau seems to cooperate with Luccar and ignore bigheaded

2016/07/25 Bigheaded oposes M. Poireau’s idea for defending of players under mass suspicions

2016/08/14 Bigheaded appears to support eliminating M. Poireau

Neutral

2016/07/13 bigheaded: no message and  2016/07/16 Luccar10: got message from bigheaded

2016/09/15 Snife and Oljo both gift bigheaded a territory.

2017/02/24 after all AI got eliminated, bigheaded was eager on starting a search for mafia.

2017/04/12 in case of boots Bluepotato thinks about keeping stacks on borders and also suspects quiter players of potentially being mafia.

2017/04/12 Niobium2 allows Oilspotter to take Lush Lark Woods and also allows Vaste Resort to be taken by either by bigheaded or bluepotato.

2017/04/28 oilspotter, bigheaded and bluepotato asked for voting (3 mafia were alive at that point)

2017/05/03 Bigheaded: To be honest, I’m not really sure who to vote for. The only person who has seemed remotely suspicious to me is Phakh, and I don’t know about anyone else.

Bad

mafgam

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s